A client asked me a question last month that I didn't have a ready answer for. He runs a kitchen design showroom near Chesterfield, and he'd typed "best kitchen designer near me" into ChatGPT out of curiosity. His biggest competitor came back with a full recommendation, a description of their style, and a line about why they'd suit a family renovation. He wasn't mentioned at all.
That's the new front door to your business, and most Derbyshire and East Midlands SMB owners haven't noticed it's open. Being recommended by ChatGPT, Gemini or Copilot isn't a gimmick. It's quickly becoming as important as showing up on page one of Google, because more people are starting their search for a tradesperson, a solicitor or a dentist inside an AI chat window rather than a search box.
I've spent 18 years helping small businesses get found online, and the rules for getting found are changing faster than at any point in my career. In this guide I'll walk you through exactly how ChatGPT decides who to recommend, and the practical steps you can take this month to improve your odds of being the business it mentions.
Not sure how your marketing measures up right now?
Run our free AI Visibility Checker to see whether ChatGPT and other AI tools can even find your business properly.
Check my AI visibilityWhy ChatGPT recommends some businesses and ignores others
ChatGPT doesn't crawl the web in real time the way Google does. It leans on a mix of training data, connected search results and structured information about businesses that it can verify quickly. If your business is hard to verify, it gets skipped, even if you're genuinely the best choice in Derby or Nottingham.
There are three things AI tools are checking for when they decide who to mention.
1. Consistency across the web
If your business name, address and phone number are slightly different on your website, your Google Business Profile and directory sites like Yell or Checkatrade, that inconsistency makes you harder to trust. AI models are built to spot contradictions, and an inconsistent business looks less credible than a consistent one, even a smaller one.
2. Content that actually answers questions
ChatGPT favours pages written to answer a specific question clearly. A page titled "Our Services" tells it nothing. A page that says "What does a kitchen renovation cost in Derbyshire in 2026" gives it something to quote.
3. Third-party proof
Reviews, press mentions and directory listings act as evidence. One of our East Midlands clients, Etta Plumbing in Osmaston, Derby, now ranks on page one for "plumbers Derby" and "plumbers near me" after we built out more than 30 local blog posts and tidied up their listings. That same groundwork that improved their Google ranking also makes them easier for an AI tool to confidently recommend.
"AI visibility isn't a separate skill from SEO. It's SEO done properly, with a layer of structured honesty on top." — Stuart Baddiley, Optimise Your Marketing
The seven things that actually move the needle
I'll be straight with you: there's a lot of noise online about "GEO" and "AI SEO" right now, and plenty of it is overcomplicated. Here's what genuinely matters for a Derbyshire or East Midlands SMB.
Get your NAP consistent everywhere
Name, Address, Phone number. The same, word for word, on your website, your Google Business Profile, Yell, Checkatrade, Facebook and any trade body listing. This is boring, unglamorous work. It's also one of the highest-leverage things you can do this week.
Write pages that answer real questions
Look at what your customers actually ask you on the phone or in person, then write a page or blog post that answers that exact question in plain English. "How much does X cost in [your town]" and "how long does X take" are two of the most reliably useful formats.
Add schema markup to your website
Schema is a bit of structured code that tells search engines and AI tools exactly what your business is, what it does, and where it's based, rather than leaving them to guess from your page copy. If that sentence meant nothing to you, that's fine. It's exactly the kind of technical groundwork our team handles for clients.
Get listed in the directories AI tools actually trust
Not every directory carries equal weight. Established, well-moderated listings (think trade bodies, recognised review platforms, local chamber of commerce sites) carry more signal than a random low-quality directory that exists purely for backlinks.
Collect reviews consistently, not in bursts
A steady trickle of reviews over months looks more natural and more trustworthy to an algorithm than 40 reviews in one week followed by silence. Build review collection into how you close every job.
Make sure your site can actually be read by AI crawlers
Some websites, particularly ones built heavily on JavaScript, are genuinely difficult for AI tools to read. If your site loads slowly or hides its content behind interactive elements, you may be invisible to the tools that matter most in 2026, regardless of how good your copy is.
Publish regularly, not once a year
A website that hasn't been updated since 2022 signals, fairly or not, a business that might not be trading any more. Regular blog content, even one post a month, keeps you visibly active.
What this looks like when it works
Our legal sector client saw web traffic grow roughly tenfold after we rebuilt their site structure and content around real search questions, the same groundwork that now helps AI tools find and trust them.
See our AI marketing serviceA simple way to test where you stand today
Open ChatGPT, Gemini or Copilot right now and type the question a customer would type. "Best [your trade] in [your town]." See what comes back. If you're missing entirely, that's your starting point, not a reason to panic. Most small businesses in Derbyshire and the East Midlands are in exactly the same position, which means there's a real window to get ahead of competitors who haven't noticed yet.
- Search your own business name plus your town in ChatGPT and Gemini
- Check your NAP matches exactly across your top five online listings
- Read your three most recent blog posts and ask whether they answer a real question
- Check whether your website has basic schema markup (your developer or agency can confirm this in minutes)
- Count how many reviews you've had in the last 90 days
How this connects to the bigger picture
AI visibility isn't a standalone project. It's the AI pillar of the BIG12, the framework I built from 18 years of watching what actually moves the needle for small businesses, sitting alongside SEO, Website, Local and Google in our Get Found cluster. Fix AI visibility in isolation and you'll see a small lift. Fix it alongside the other eleven pillars and the results compound, because each one reinforces the others.
That's the whole point of the BIG12. It's not another marketing fad. It's the twelve things every business in Derbyshire and the East Midlands genuinely needs to get right online, mapped out so you can see exactly where the gaps are.
See where AI visibility sits in your bigger marketing picture
Our free BIG12 Scorecard benchmarks all twelve pillars in a few minutes, so you can see exactly where to focus next.
Take the BIG12 ScorecardThe challenge is never learning. It is doing.
None of what I've covered here is a secret. Most of it is sitting in a dozen different blog posts across the internet already, written by agencies far bigger than mine. The gap isn't knowledge. It's the twenty small, unglamorous jobs that need doing consistently, month after month, while you're also running the actual business.
I see this constantly across Derbyshire and the East Midlands. A business owner reads the guide, nods along, means to fix their NAP listings that weekend, and then a customer calls, a job overruns, and three months pass with nothing changed. That's not a failure of intent. It's just what running a business does to a to-do list.
This is exactly where we come in. We don't just tell you what to fix, we fix it, then measure whether it worked and adjust.
Book a free 90-minute audit with Stuart
We will look at your current marketing, benchmark it against the BIG12, and give you a practical set of actions to take. No sales pitch. No fluff. Just 18 years of honest advice applied to your business.
Book my free audit